CO129-347 - Governor Sir Lugard - 1908 [4-6] — Page 68

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All

66

avad I dɔidw sonevetng aḍT .Intoq sit ton at tært duk

.TO/BI

Jært at ynolod edt of emao darit I sonła nere bøjstetter braØN

sdt gairub emit arsqa a'embut, szelvi odt satiktu od taqvo I

,ob nadto vadt awond flow at di as ,tto og aessɔ aid ti‚xoow

Lade I Holdw „ytIvolttib mist of .batsqloltas nsdë reÌITSO

noltasaqua a'd‡im2 . Tetsi mtaiqze of wovasbus brs of teteT

tud,wond [Is aw Jarîw to Jnemetsta a vínnem et di .rswana on ai

mort nabbid sia ajoat suit and dent yaw a doun ni brawrot duq

.bauamtbbs at 31 modw oð batm val odd

edit" tant bataannua evari of amosa ditima TH

*

..

eft vɗ neist ed bivore votqımıánaf nt anolisalnaxe olduq

to moltent telɗo sdt bæe,187telya? vtuqed rolne2 to 1sitatgef

.* .**k noqu rabro aid exam bra troqar sit evləoat sgbul enzluq

yətqurdnad to adnemofs art wom! Jon asob ỵltnsraqqs ríðisë

sandt terit som:troqui taomtu aɗt to al #1 .moltentalni ba

art azoted betsubnos ad blwoda molod aids at anoltanimaxa

--#MOE (#Todt bra nedt shart ed of evad netto arabro rot,●gbut

no vlanitas basqah doldw Totdeb and to Jaetta edit tot semid-

*

Tobru rotvaded aid to embub ent yď bevisser anolaserqnt ad?

anlob tia of avari I BA‚Xчow awothet taomi arið at $I „rottantmaxe

tud ja to him toŋ vigat!Itw blwow I bra redeti tuď gniston

TO leem ti ob blwona I tedd el ti jastroqni word word I tarið

•Show vat prasƐ gnidad at ed nedfw ogbul onelu¶ sdt eawoo to

10.

Your Excellency says (paragraph 7) that

"experience in the past seems to show that neither illness of

one of the Judges, nor exceptionally heavy cases lasting from

16 to 18 days have produced a deadlock". I do not know whether

the illness of a Judge has raised any serious questions in the

past, and judging by the Tables of work for 1904, it could have

made no difference to the work of the Court. But it stands to

reason, I submit, that if the Chief Justice falls ill the cases

he had fixed for trial must be postponed, or else the Puisne

Judge must take them, and upset his own arrangements. But the

more important part of the sentence is the one based on Mr.

Smith's statement about the length of exceptionally heavy casos

and their effect. Your Excellency doubtless imagines that these

heavy cases were of frequent occurrence, or Mr. Smith would not

have laid stress upon them. There has during many years only

been one case lasting 18 days. There seems to have been one

lasting 10 days before I came, and there has been one I think

since; so that this statement of Mr. Smith is couched in such a

form as to be misleading as to the facts. But it is also mis-

-leading in the inference which is drawn from it. A long case

produces no deadlock because its probable length is known and

estimated for beforehand. It produces delay in bringing on other

cases for trial, but not a deadlock. It is necessary therefore

to

it's

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.